Below are a few of Peerage of Science peer reviews with high PEQ-scores, featured as examples of what good but critical peer review looks like. As the manuscripts under review are not yet published, the manuscript title and some peer review content is censored. Note that these peer reviews are only from the first stage of the process and therefore The present paper offers a review of the oral manifestations of various gastrointestinal (GI) dis-eases diagnosed in patients admitted in our depart-ment. The review includes peptic ulcer disease, chronic gastritis, gastric cancer, chronic hepatic diseases, gallbladder and biliary diseases, and chronic pancreatitis. Material and method A scientific literature review is a critical account of what has been published on a topic by accredited researchers. It may be: • A stand-alone assignment • An introduction to an essay, report, thesis, etc. • Part of research/grant proposals. Scientific Literature Review: Writing a literature review will: • Improve your topic knowledge • Provide File Size: 1MB
Essay Examples: Critical Review Assignment
Home » Essay Examples » Critical Review Assignment. The research topic discussed concerns the existence of statistics anxiety among graduate students. One primary question is whether or not there is a prevalence of procrastination among such students. Research data reveals that approximately 80 percent of students experience higher than average anxiety levels. Further, research seeks to investigate the relationship between academic procrastination and six dimensions of statistics anxiety Onwuegbuzie, There are several methodologies for both gathering and analyzing data.
One research methodology is the use of canonical correlation. Canonical correlation is useful as a tool to both identify and measure intercorrelated outcome variables UCLA Institute for Digital Research and Education, Another methodology used for identifying the six components of statistics anxiety i. interpretation anxiety, computational self-concept is factor analysis. Factor analysis is useful for the exploration of relevant patterns in the data. According to Norman Streiner, often the critical review of scientific paper example result is either confirmation of a hypotheses, or minimization of variables John Critical review of scientific paper example Bloomberg School of Public Health, The three primary areas are related to writing term papers, examination study, and weekly reading assignments.
One identified causative factor is the level of importance placed on completing assignments which leads to aversive behaviors Onwuegbuzie, The study is qualitative in nature, and identifies a perfectionistic behavior among graduate students, critical review of scientific paper example.
The perfectionist behavior is either due to self-orientation or social factors. The recommendation is that students have an awareness of the interconnection between procrastination, perfectionism, and achievement Onwuegbuzie, Part A of the purpose statement seeks to address the prevalence of procrastination among graduate students.
Part B aptly examines the relationship between academic procrastination and the six dimensions of statistics anxiety Onwuegbuzie, The research problem is clearly stated and offers a definitive scope of study. The researcher clearly provides the reader with an outline of intended study topic. The three primary sections in the article are method which includes instruments and procedureresults, and discussion.
The article which is qualitative in nature could actually be considered a mixed-method approach. This is because it incorporates significant statistical data that is empirical in nature. Critical review of scientific paper example, it would not appear to be of recent origin. Furthermore, the journal article is from which is greater than a decade since origin. It then purports that it is likely that statistics anxiety is associated with student procrastination in completing research courses Onwuegbuzie, In other words, the hypothesis is implicit or suggested following the data about the large number of graduate students experiencing statistics anxiety.
Overall it is consistent with the discussion in the literature review. Ethical Standards Applied In the method section the study indicates that participation was both voluntary and anonymous. Prerequisites to participation included a critical review of scientific paper example consent by all participants. The stated incentive was extra course credit, which could account for percent participation rate Onwuegbuzie, What could have improved the analysis of the applied ethical standards was a template that included the written consent form.
Critical review of scientific paper example participants appeared to be protected from harm as it appears that no individualized data is revealed. Rather the focus is on data like mean academic achievement, grade point average, and study gender, critical review of scientific paper example. This conclusion is of course deductive as there are remaining questions such as the location of the data following the study. Operational Definitions It does not appear that all terms, theories, and concepts are clearly identified although critical terms appear to be.
For example statistics anxiety is understood as apprehension resulting from individual encounters with statistics Onwuegbuzie, However, when referring to a methodology like factor analysis, the assumption is that the reader is already familiar with the term.
It would have also been nice to see the key search terms identified at the beginning of the report, critical review of scientific paper example. Methodology The methodology section which identifies the research design as qualitative is very detailed and objective. For example some of the instruments used like the non-parametric Wilcoxon two-sample t-test were supported by findings from other studies.
Additional instrument included the Statistical Anxiety Rating Scale STARS and the Procrastination Assessment Scale-Students PASS. The inclusion of information such as who developed the instrument and its functionality creates a sense of the appropriate nature of the instruments.
The present study has a mean procrastination score of However, what is unknown is the impact of variables such as participant age and number of participants. In the present study the age range was with a mean age of In contrast the Solomon and Rothblum study had a age range of Onwuegbuzie, This may have had a greater impact on the data outcome compared to the participant number, which is still noteworthy.
Discussion Strengths of the study include the detailed nature of participant attitudes toward reducing procrastination. The statistical data is categorized based on specific areas of procrastination such as writing term papers The hypothesis was aptly identified and supported based on the inclusion of an assortment of empirical data. One potential study limitation was the lack of pilot studies.
In the absence of such a study the researcher leveraged data from previous studies. One significant recommendation was for instructors to assist students in the strategies for reducing procrastination. Suggested disciplines include time management and study skills counseling Onwuegbuzie, References The books, journals, and other relevant references are appropriately and accurately referenced. The proper APA format is used as well as the end-text reference list which is listed alphabetically.
Conclusion In conclusion considering all the evaluation categories, the article is well researched. The end result should be ongoing and continuous studies. For example a future study may undertake a project to determine baseline results of anxiety, 6 month, and 12 month results following some of the recommendations.
This way it can be determined whether the suggested recommendations effectively reduce student anxiety concerning the aforementioned areas. The study also indicated that procrastination amongst students can also be found in weekly readings. In critical review of scientific paper example more students in the graduate study report a propensity to procrastinate on weekly readings than undergraduate students Onwuegbuzie, So school administrators, curriculum designers, and teachers should begin to request feedback from students regarding ways to make the weekly readings more exciting and engaging.
Coughlan, critical review of scientific paper example, M. Step-by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 1: quantitative research. British Journal of Nursing, 16 11 John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
Statistics in Psychosocial Research Lecture 8 Factor Analysis 1. Critical review of scientific paper example, A. Academic procrastination and statistics anxiety. UCLA Institute for Digital Research and Education.
R Data Analysis Examples: Canonical Correlation Analysis. We are U. We hold graduate and professional degrees from major universities Princeton, critical review of scientific paper example, Stanford, UCLA,Georgetown, Dartmouth, Penn, Northwestern.
This is all that we do. Powered by SharkPapers. Essay Examples - Critical Review Assignment Home » Essay Examples » Critical Review Assignment Article Summary The research topic discussed concerns the existence of statistics anxiety among graduate students. References Coughlan, M. pdf Onwuegbuzie, A. Who are we? Learn More. All rights reserved.
LOGIN TO YOUR ACCOUNT. No account? Sign up Forgot Password? SIGN UP TO YOUR ACCOUNT. Log in Forgot Password? FORGOT PASSWORD. Login Sign up.
EDLM505 Critical Review of a Journal Article
, time: 13:33How to Write an Article Review: Full Guide with Examples | EssayPro
Below are a few of Peerage of Science peer reviews with high PEQ-scores, featured as examples of what good but critical peer review looks like. As the manuscripts under review are not yet published, the manuscript title and some peer review content is censored. Note that these peer reviews are only from the first stage of the process and therefore Examples of validity testing in the study include the statement, “the PASS scale mean was compared to the mean reported by the developers of the PASS (Onwuegbuzie, ).”. There is no awareness of a pilot study that was conducted. Data Analysis/Results In this study there were graduate students that participated in the study Edanz Expert Scientific Review Report Prepared by: Sample GSample Introduction Does the introduction provide sufficient background information for readers not in the immediate field to understand the problem/hypotheses? The introduction provides a good, generalized background of the topic that quickly gives the reader an
No comments:
Post a Comment